India and I are in the middle of a knock-down, drag-out fight, replete with commands to "Go to your room, young lady, and don't come out again until you can behave!" Followed by, "Fine! I want to go to my room anyway! And don't come in!" Punctuated by slamming doors and thumping feet.
Want to know what triggered this donnybrook? A birthday party. Not only that, but this birthday party hasn't even happened yet.
Here's the backstory: Celeste got her first invitation to a birthday party sans older sister, and India is ragingly jealous. My rather avaricious elder daughter is having a hard time accepting the concept that her sister is going to have fun she isn't going to have, and is going to get something she isn't getting, and it's killing her. So India issued an edict that "Ceecee HAS to share her goody bag with me!" Well, no, she doesn't. I will spare you the play-by-play, but the argument on my side boiled down to, we don't make you share your goody bag toys with Celeste, so she doesn't need to share them with you. The argument on India's side boiled down to, that's not fair, "not fair" being interpreted in this situation as, "any situation I don't like".
There are two facets to this issue, one being that India is just experiencing the first inklings of the fact that her sister is, in fact, a completely separate human being who is not always going to trail around in Big Sister's shadow. I have pointed out, in a total and complete waste of breath, that India has had a three-year head start on birthday parties, friendships, goodie bag procurement, parental attention, etc. etc., and it is only natural that Celeste is going to enjoy some of the same as she gets older. The other facet is the completely and totally ridiculous symbol of suburban overconsumption and overachievement, that being the birthday party goody bag.
I have made no secret of the fact that I hate goody bags and the stuff that comes in them. When I was attending kid parties, back when the earth was cooling and party invitations were painted on cave walls, there was no such thing as a goody bag. You were just psyched to get cake and ice cream in your young years, along with pizza, soda, chips and candy in the tween phase. Sometimes the host gave out little prizes for winning party games like Pin the Tail on the Donkey, or my current favorite game, Let's See Who Can Leave Mommy Alone the Longest, but that was it. Somewhere in the three-plus decades between my last kid party and my childrens' first, the idea that the party itself was treat enough for the attendees fell out of favor (no one thought to inform me of that fact, because I certainly wouldn't have approved). Living as we now do in the land of hypercompetitive parenting, the whole goody bag scenario has taken on the nature of the nuclear arms race of the 80's. Here's an illustration: At India's fifth birthday, I decided that I'd have the kids decorate paper lunch bags, thus turning the goody bag into an activity as well as a favor. Then the kids could use their goody bags to carry the pinata candy home. (I also gave out packets of flower seeds that I got at a discount store which refused to sprout, so I guess I did contribute to the birthday-party waste stream, but I tried to keep it to a minimum.) After the pinata was beaten into submission, one of India's little pals wandered up to me and asked, "What's going in the goody bags? Where are the favors?"
"You already got it," I pointed out. "It's for your candy."
Her little face fell. "That's it?" she said, in tones that conveyed equal amounts of disbelief, amazement, and contempt. Apparently a party that includes a bounce house, sprinkler play, arts and crafts, bubble blowing, a pinata, a hotdog lunch and cake and ice cream is a washout unless it includes a bag filled to overflowing with crappy plastic doodads manufactured in unsafe working conditions by people whose daily pay is outstripped by the cost of the goody bag's contents. Furthermore, the whole philosophy behind giving out the goody bags irks me. Somewhere along the line, someone decided that being a middle-class kid from a nice family meant that your kid should never experience any unpleasantness or discomfort. Does your kid cry because the birthday boy is getting all kinds of swag and she's not? Instead of telling her that that's the way life is sometimes, you'll have a birthday one day and no one else will get presents, you get to point out, look! there's a goody bag! And, since you're trying to keep up with the Joneses next door, YOUR goody bags have to be bigger and better than the goody bags at THEIR kid's party were.
I swear, the next birthday party in our house is going to have a Tibetan Buddhist theme. We're going to renounce worldly goods and drink yak-butter tea before volunteering in a leper colony. The face masks and antibacterial hand gel can count as the party favors.
EDITED TO ADD: Here are some comments my Facebook friends made that are worth adding:
Sue: I wholeheartedly agree!! (surprise surprise) Goody bags rank right up
there with giving the siblings presents on birthdays so they don't feel
left out.
Joanne: I think goody-bags should be given out at meetings -- and the longer
the meeting, the better the swag. (And no, H1N1 prevention brochures do
NOT count as swag.)
Me: See?
Goody bags should be reserved for making unpleasant occasions more
bearable. A birthday party is supposed to be fun in and of itself. I
shouldn't have to bribe kids to want to be there with a buncha junk.